I generally enjoy reading Pratap Bhanu Mehta's essays, specially his always trenchant analysis of Indian politics. His essay last week is a fine exemplar, outlining the deeper institutional difficulties that face Prime Minister Modi, which Modi unfortunately does not seem to be paying much attention to. Mehta's position is always that of a true Liberal, and he appears not to take a position first and let the analysis follow, but decide on his position based on his analysis. Such analytical commitment and honesty is rare anywhere but especially in India.
But Liberalism has serious flaws when it comes to understanding international politics. I had earlier posted a brief comment on another essay of his where I disagreed with his view of Indian policy on Pakistan, which he characterized as Realism. His latest essay gives me another chance to provide a brief Realist critique of the Liberal view of India-Pakistan relations.